Many people have made negative comments about the Go Dai No Kata elemental system Mr. Hayes uses. Especially now in To-Shin Do since the examples he uses are not the same as the classical material it was derived from. I think they have confused the gathering and labeling of information with understanding. I’ll hear things like:
“There’s no water element in Ujyaku from the Churyaku no Maki of Gyokko Ryu. It’s done like this…”
Oh that was real enlightening, thanks, I can read the notes too. Hell, I can watch it on my computer anytime I want.
That’s just information. Understanding how these elemental LABELS (you could just as easily call them 1,2,3,4,5 instead) represent emotional thought patterns of survival in conflict can safe your life.
So are the elements the “beginnings” to a conflict and interchangeable as the situation develops?
Yes…beginnings, middle, ending, even the shakes you get afterward from the adrenaline leaving your body can all be labeled by one of the element names. They can change at any moment depending on how you feel and the conditions of the conflict at that moment.
I have a woman training with me who asked a very similar question about how the elements work. We were working on Koyoku from the earth level material and she was having a difficult time holding her ground against my hook punch. She knew this was an ‘earth’ technique and that she should be strong and confident but being a rather slender person and me being 6′2″ and 250 pounds she wasn’t really feeling that way.
She has a young four year old. I told her to pretend her son was behind her and that I was trying to get to him to hurt him. Her body lowered, her gaze steadied right on me and when I threw the hook she blasted it back and away. She was shocked at her own power.
We came up with similar ideas for ‘her’ for each of the elements. Like for fire I told her son was behind me and I was going to keep him from her. After I picked my self up off my butt I told her I felt she was starting to get the idea…
With water I told her it was just the two of us in this fight but she still had to make it home to her son. Obviously I’m bigger and stronger but she still had to win (survive). What technology or idea was she going to use to defeat me despite my advantages?
For Wind I asked her if her son ever charged into her or attempted to hit her while playing. Her answer was “yes he’s four”. She needs to control him but she doesn’t want him or her to get hurt. So I told her to pretend I was Evan as I attacked and she responded with a wind level technique.
The key to this was that we found ideas for ‘her’. What you have to do is find what works for you.
What could you imagine that would make you stand your ground and defend no matter what? That answer could help you with Earth.
What could you imagine that would make you think, “This situation/attacker is dangerous, I need to find a smart way out of this”? That would help with Water.
What could you imagine that would make you so connected to the person in front of you that the slightest movement makes you rush forward into the situation? That could help with Fire.
What could you imagine that would enable you to feel compassion in the middle of chaos so that you could control the situation but not hurt anyone? That could help you with Wind.
These elements are a combination of self-exploration and really cool martial arts concepts. To understand them and use them you have to look inside. Probably the reason so many people attack Mr. Hayes about them is that if they were to accept them they would have to look past their delusions of grandeur.
Dennis
Shinobi Martial Arts
95 Plaistow Road, Plaistow NH